Three little boys were arguing over whose father was the richest. The first boy said, “My dad is the richest because he owns the biggest farm in the county.” The second boy said, “That’s nothing! My dad is the richest because he owns the biggest bank in town.” Then they both turned to the third boy and said, “Bet your dad doesn’t own anything because he’s a pastor.” The minister’s son replied, “Oh yeah? My dad owns something bigger than a farm or a bank. He owns hell.” The other boys laughed and said, “That’s crazy! How do you know your dad owns hell?” The PK replied, “When my dad came home from church last night, I heard him tell Mom that the board gave him hell!”
Just like that pastor’s kid, most churchgoers have no idea what really goes on behind-the-scenes at the average church. What really happens in meetings of the board and staff? How many decisions are really made on the basis of Scripture and prayer? How do the key leaders really behave when they’re immersed in a crisis?
When I first joined a church staff – and later when I became a pastor – I was horrified at how many decisions in a church were made on the basis of politics, pure and simple. I was shocked because I thought Christian leaders would make spiritual decisions rather than political ones. While I have been in churches where the leaders truly “walked the walk” in every situation, I have also been in churches where the leaders seem to forget they’re in a church.
The best illustration in the Bible of politics in action occurs when the Sanhedrin sent Jesus to Pontius Pilate, the Roman governor. Let me share with you five political strategies that Pilate used that I have seen used in local churches:
First, politicians succumb to outside pressure. When Jesus was first brought before Pilate, the Jewish leaders accused Him of “subverting our nation. He opposes payment of taxes to Caesar and claims to be Christ, a king” (Luke 23:2). In other words, Jesus was accused of trying to overthrow Rome. But after Pilate initially questioned Jesus, he told His accusers, “I find no basis for a charge against this man” (Luke 23:4). And yet, when Jesus’ countrymen continued to accuse Him of stirring up the people, Pilate lost his nerve and backed down.
In my first pastorate, the board chairman asked me to take action over a theological issue involving two of his family members. After I researched the issue, I presented relevant materials to the board in a three-hour meeting, after which we made a unanimous decision. When I tried to explain our decision to the family members, they threatened to leave the church and demanded a personal apology. When I asked the board for support, they flipped on me and told me to apologize, but I refused. (I’d like to say it’s because of divine courage but it could also be because of my stubborn Germany ancestry.) I reminded them that we had made a decision together based on Scripture, but that didn’t matter to them.
While politicians wilt when pressured, spiritual leaders stand strong.
Second, politicians avoid the tough calls. Dr. Luke tells us that when Pilate heard that Jesus was a Galilean, he sent Jesus to see the ruler of Galilee, King Herod, who was visiting the Holy City for Passover. Pilate hoped that Herod would make a decision about Jesus’ fate that would take the Roman governor off the hook, but Herod merely ridiculed Jesus and sent him back to Pilate.
I once stumbled upon some inappropriate material on the social networking site of an important person in my church. I consulted with that person’s supervisor who promised to address the issue, but months later, the objectionable material was still there.
While a politician prefers not to confront a friend, a spiritual leader seeks that person’s repentance and restoration.
Third, politicians scapegoat innocent people. Which crimes had Jesus commited against Rome? He hadn’t committed any. Pilate twice confessed that Jesus was innocent of all the charges hurled His way (Luke 23:4, 14), but instead of exonerating and then releasing Him, Pilate decided to punish Jesus (by beating) before releasing Him. Why? This is what His vocal constituents demanded even though Jesus was blameless before the law. Rather than declaring Jesus completely innocent, Pilate declared Jesus partly innocent.
I’ll write more about this story another time, but I know a church where the pastor resigned because a member of his family was accused of a crime they didn’t commit. No one in that church moved a finger to right the wrong – until the new pastor came. When he heard the truth, he arranged for the former pastor to return to the church. In public, those who falsely accused the pastor admitted their error, the church asked his forgiveness for permitting a grave injustice, and the pastor and church experienced a liberating reconciliation that allowed both parties to move on with God’s blessing.
While politicians apportion blame for conflicts indiscriminately, spiritual leaders apportion blame accurately.
Fourth, politicians don’t seek divine wisdom. With the Sanhedrin breathing down his neck, Pilate did not seek guidance from Scripture, or a prophet, or prayer. God tried to speak to him through a dream that He gave Pilate’s wife (Matthew 27:19), but Pilate brushed off the message. He was used to making unilateral decisions based on Roman interests + common sense, but both of those touchstones failed him at this juncture. Had he only looked above instead of around … history might have judged him differently.
You might not like this, but I have been in scores of board meetings where the board members – who have been chosen primarily because of their walk with God – never even consider consulting God when they get stuck on an issue. They don’t quote Scripture or turn to key passages. They don’t stop the meeting to consult with the Lord in prayer. I have even been in meetings where the meeting wasn’t opened with prayer. It’s like the Lord isn’t even there. Board members just discuss issues using worldly wisdom but never truly seek the Lord’s mind on anything.
While politicians consult exclusively with their peers or constituents, spiritual leaders initially seek the Lord’s face on everything.
Finally, politicians want to look good. They care more about their image than their character. They care more about how they appear to others than how they appear to God. John makes a profound statement about many of the Jewish leaders who believed in Jesus but would not confess Him openly: “For they loved praise from men more than praise from God” (John 12:43).
Stuart Briscoe from Elmbrook Church in Wisconsin is one of my all-time favorite preachers. I once heard him make this simple but profound observation: “Most people want to feel good and look good. They don’t want to be good and do good.”
While politicians are primarily concerned with feeling good and looking good so they can be re-elected, spiritual leaders care more about being good and doing good – even if that means they’re one-termers.
If we’re serious about wanting God’s blessing on our churches, if we truly wish to obey God’s Word, if we want to impact our communities for Jesus, if we want to see revival in our time – then we need to stop making decisions in our churches purely on the basis of politics and start making decisions on the basis of righteousness.
I dare you to try it. In fact, I double dog dare you.
Another solid gold piece! I especially liked the quote by Stuart Briscoe and think he is completely correct. Being good in action and deed is harder than being perceived as being good. Something we should all think about and strive for.
LikeLike
I also like Stuart Briscoe because he is very human and truly funny – and his books are an easy read as well.
LikeLike
Very helpful, Jim.
I’m meeting with one of the “higher-ups” at church on Tuesday over some unscriptural Bible study material that found its way into the “Moms” ministry.
Someone didn’t do their job, and now we have a situation.
A hundred women have bought the book at $13 dollars a pop, and we have seen the first video….
I’m trying to stop a moving train.
LikeLike
I was under the assumption that only men’s ministries propogated heresy! These things happen in churches when steps are missed, and that can happen when people are stressed and make faulty assumptions. Please tell Darrell happy birthday from me! I think of you guys many times in the course of a year.
LikeLike
I need to say thank you very much for that work you have made in writing this blog post. I am hoping the same perfect job by you down the road also.
LikeLike
Wow… sad to say this is so common… thanks for writing this. Recently I wrote about ten toxic responses in handling issues, while I did not use the word “politics”, it is politics in the working, joining in the discussion … http://truthsetsfree.me/2014/10/13/ten-toxic-responses-to-issues-and-problems/
LikeLike
Thanks for writing. I’ve always felt that a pastor needs to know where the politics are in the church, but should never “play” politics. But church leaders … even pastors … do it all the time. I’ll check out your article. Thanks again!
Jim
LikeLiked by 1 person
Jesus played no politics. I don’t think Paul did neither. Only in Christ and in His Spirit would there be unity. Unless the church is a group of Christ disciples who seek after God, and Christ is truly the Head, otherwise, when Christ is not in charge of the church, politics is used by church leaders lead by the flesh. Sad to say there are too many of them.
LikeLike