Imagine that you own a business. You have ten employees.
Because business hasn’t been going well recently, you have to lay off two workers.
Eight employees are loyal and work hard. Two have conspired to attack you behind your back and don’t do much of anything.
Your decision is a no-brainer, right?
Now imagine that you’re a board member in a congregation of 200 adults
Ten individuals … meaning five percent of your congregation … have abused, slandered, and attacked your pastor to the point that he has resigned.
As a church leader, what are you going to do about it?
If you follow the New Testament, the decision is simple for you and your fellow board members:
Confront the troublemakers and give them a choice: either repent of your sin or leave the church.
Those who are truly spiritually-oriented will repent. Those who aren’t will leave the church kicking and screaming … but if you mean business, they will leave.
But how often do board members confront those who pushed out their pastor?
Hardly ever.
Why not?
It could be because board members:
*don’t think the troublemakers did anything wrong.
*are afraid of the troublemakers.
*are friends with the troublemakers.
*are ignorant of the New Testament’s directives on divisive individuals.
*know the New Testament’s directives but choose to ignore them.
*leave the thankless task to an interim pastor.
*reason, “We need all the attendees, donors, and volunteers we can get … even if they are troublemakers.”
*are so exhausted after the pastor’s departure that they don’t even consider confronting anybody.
However … there is a price to be paid for failing to confront the troublemakers, and it’s a high price indeed:
Many of your church’s spiritual, healthy, and valuable people will leave.
Imagine these two scenarios:
Lisa had been away from church for years, but she came back to the Lord because of Pastor Bill.
She rarely missed his sermons … joined a small group … discovered her spiritual gifts and began serving in a ministry … and became a generous giver.
But every Sunday when she comes to church now, she sees five troublemakers sitting together, and she says to herself, “Those are the people who pushed out my pastor.”
If she confronts them, she’s liable to blow her top. So she stays silent … and simmers … and assumes that nobody ever addressed the troublemakers.
Going to church eventually becomes such an unpleasant experience that she leaves the church for good.
Paul received emails from the troublemakers denouncing Pastor Bill on a regular basis.
At first, the notes made him feel important, but after a few weeks, they upset him and made him feel like a traitor, so he began deleting them without reading them.
But Paul knows the troublemakers were telling twisted lies about Pastor Bill, and he wonders why they seem to be immune from correction.
When it’s time for the church to vote on new board members, two troublemakers are nominated, and Paul feels sick inside.
How can he attend and support a church where the people who attacked and slandered his pastor have been placed into leadership?
So Paul slips out the back door … and never attends that church again.
Dr. Leith Anderson is one of America’s foremost pastors and thinkers. I had the privilege of taking my last Doctor of Ministry course with him at Fuller Seminary. In his book Leadership That Works, Anderson writes about the failure of church leaders to discipline church troublemakers:
“The result is that the church keeps the dissenters and loses the happy, healthy people to other churches. Most healthy Christians have a time limit and a tolerance level for unchristian and unhealthy attitudes and behaviors.”
Do church leaders know that when they ignore divisive behavior they are alienating the very people they need to make their church productive?
If leaders don’t confront the troublemakers, the following things will happen:
*Church morale will plunge.
*Many of the pastor’s supporters will leave.
*Giving will take a dive.
*The church’s heart will be cut out.
*The troublemakers will stay around to cause trouble again.
*The church may never recover.
*God will withhold His blessing until the leaders do what is right.
It’s happening all over America:
When a group attacks their pastor, the troublemakers stay, and many solid Christian people leave.
Doesn’t sound like a good deal, does it?
Then why does it happen so often?
One Way to Resolve Church Conflicts
Posted in Church Conflict, Conflict with Church Antagonists, Conflict with the Pastor, Fighting Evil, Pastoral Termination, Please Comment!, tagged church conflict, Korah's rebellion, Numbers 16, pastoral termination on June 20, 2014| Leave a Comment »
I’ve recently been doing an intensive study of Numbers 16 … the story of Korah’s rebellion against Moses and Aaron.
Korah and three of his colleagues … along with 250 community leaders … decide that they don’t want to follow Moses’ leadership anymore.
Why not?
The group approaches Moses and Aaron and says in Numbers 16:3: “You have gone too far! The whole community is holy, every one of them, and the Lord is with them. Why then do you set yourselves above the Lord’s assembly?”
Translation: “There is nothing special about you two leaders. We are just as holy as you are. So why are you always telling us what to do? We’re not going to take it anymore!”
Moses and Aaron were old men. It’s possible that Korah was much younger and felt he could do a better job at overseeing priestly duties than Aaron could.
But as the story proceeds, it’s obvious that God sides with Moses and Aaron and opposes the attempted coup.
Most church conflicts begin because a group inside the church believes that they know how to run the church better than the official leadership … usually the pastor.
Their attitude is, “We’re more spiritual than the pastor … we’re smarter … we’re more resourceful … we’re more in touch with the congregation … so we should be running the church rather than him!”
Whenever these conflicts arise in churches … and they arise all the time … most people miss the best way to resolve the conflict.
The question is not, “Who is best qualified to lead this church?”
The question is, “Who did God call to lead this church?”
Moses told the coalition in Numbers 16:11: “It is against the Lord that you and all your followers have banded together.” They thought they were rebelling against two human leaders, but Moses says, “No, by rebelling against God’s leaders, you’re really rebelling against the Lord.”
Moses goes on in Numbers 16:28, “This is how you will know that the Lord has sent me to do all these things and that it was not my idea.” Then he proposes a test to determine who is on God’s side and who is not.
Early in my ministry, I inherited a church board full of wonderful men … all except for Don.
Don wanted to take our church back to the 1950s – even though it was the late 1980s – and he wanted us to reinvent ourselves into a small, Midwestern church … even though we were located in California.
I was trying to take the church forward, while he insisted we go backward.
Don had not been called by God to pastor a church … but he was called by friends to lead a rebellion.
Don had not been formally trained in biblical interpretation or pastoral ministry … but he knew something about politics and power.
Don had not been given the spiritual gifts of leadership or teaching … but he didn’t need those gifts to subvert his pastor.
Don had not been ordained to gospel ministry … but that didn’t matter to him.
Don held secret meetings … listed all my faults, including those of my wife and children … and then demanded that I resign.
The elders of Israel supported Moses and stood by him … and the elders in our church did the same.
Don’s group quickly left the church … started their own church a mile away … and used our church as their mission field.
But a year later, their church folded.
God had called Don to be a dock worker, not a pastor.
And He had called me to be a pastor, not a dock worker.
God had called Moses to lead Israel, not Korah.
And He had called Korah to be a Levite, not the leader of a nation.
Many church conflicts could be resolved if God’s people would take some time to read Scripture … do some reflection … and ask this question:
Who did God call to lead this congregation?
If the answer is Moses … follow him.
If the answer is your pastor … follow him.
But if you follow Korah … or Don … things aren’t going to work out for you … guaranteed.
All you’re going to do is hurt a lot of people … including you and your family.
If your pastor isn’t leading or preaching or pastoring like he could be … then pray for him … and love him … and listen to him … and support him … as long as he follows the Lord.
That’s far better than watching the ground open up and swallow you and your family whole.
Share this:
Read Full Post »